|
Survey and Research Report on the Currie
House
559 North Main Street
Davidson, North Carolina

1. Name and location of the property:
The property known as the Currie House is located at 559 North Main
Street, Davidson, North Carolina.
2. Name and address of the current owner of the
property:
The current owners of the property are:
Jon Christopher Krider and Michele M. Kolbinsky-Krider
PO Box 1273
Davidson, North Carolina
28036
(704) 892-7879
3. Representative photographs of the property:
This report contains representative photographs of the
property.
4. Maps depicting the location of the property:
A map depicting the location of the property can be
found below. The UTM of the property is 17
513966E 3929071N.

5. Current deed book reference to the property:
The most current reference to the property may be found
in Mecklenburg County Deed Book 17198 at page 123. The tax parcel
identification number for the property is 003-263-10.
6. A brief historical sketch of the property:
This report contains a brief historical sketch of the
property.
7. A brief architectural sketch of the property:
This report contains a brief architectural sketch of
the property.
8. Documentation of why and in what ways the property meets criteria for
designation set forth in N.C.G.S. 160A-400.5:
a. Special significance in terms of its historical,
prehistorical, architectural, or cultural importance: The Commission
judges that the Currie House does have special historical significance
within the context of Davidson, N.C. The Commission bases its judgment on
the following considerations:
1. The Currie family
displayed a fervent commitment to public education for the children of the
Davidson community. Archibald Currie, a long-time professor at Davidson
College, was one of the early proponents of graded education in Davidson.
His wife, Lucy Currie, and their daughter, Letitia Currie, both served as
teachers in the Davidson public education system.
2. The Currie House and its residents are
representative of the symbiotic relationship between the College and the
town that is a distinctive characteristic of Davidson.
3. Lucy Martin Currie was a
distinguished Davidsonian whose academic achievements, which are outstanding
by today’s standards, are even more impressive in light of the societal
restrictions placed upon women in the early twentieth century. Lucy was not
only one of the earliest female graduates of Davidson College, long before
the school was co-educational, but she also traveled with the first group of
Rhodes Scholars in 1904 to study in Oxford, England.
b. Integrity of design, setting, workmanship, materials,
feeling and/or association: The Commission contends that the physical
and architectural description which is included in this report demonstrates
that the Currie House meets this criterion.
9. Ad valorem tax appraisal:
The Commission is aware that designation would allow the owner to apply for
an automatic deferral of 50% of the Ad valorem taxes on all or any portion
of the property which becomes a designated "historic landmark." The current
total appraised value of the Currie House is $280,100. The current total
appraised value of the house is $155,300. The current total appraised value
of the 0.8 acre lot is $124,800.
Date of Preparation of this report: July 22, 2006
Prepared by: Jennifer K. Payne
Summary Statement of Significance
The Currie House was built in 1911 and is a highly intact, late
Victorian style home that exhibits the influence of the popular
Arts-and-Crafts movement. As the home of Archibald Currie, who served
Davidson College as a professor and the town of Davidson as an attorney, and
Lucy Martin Currie, the daughter of a family with strong ties to Davidson
College, who is remembered as having defined the “cultural tone” of the
village, the dwelling is representative of the distinctive interrelationship
between the town and the college. In addition, the Currie family was
fervently committed to public education in the town. Archibald Currie was a
proponent of the graded school movement in Davidson, and worked to bring
standardized public education to the children of the town in his roles as
one of the earliest principals of the Davidson Academy and one of the first
trustees of the graded school. Lucy Martin Currie also taught at the graded
school, as did her daughter Letitia, who is remembered as a well-loved
eighth-grade teacher at the Davidson Middle School. Lucy Martin Currie
further exemplified this commitment to education through her attainment of
academic achievements that were generally not available to women of this
era. She was one of the first female graduates of Davidson College, long
before the school was co-educational. In addition, she traveled with the
first group of American Rhodes scholars to study at Oxford University in
1904.
Historical Context Statement
Davidson College, which was established in 1835 to educate young men
according to the values of the school’s Presbyterian founders, has provided
the impetus for the evolution and development of the Town of Davidson. From
1835 to 1874, the town was a relatively isolated college community; and its
growth was almost exclusively linked to the increasing number of students
and faculty who attended or taught at Davidson College. Not only was the
built environment of Davidson in this period characterized by faculty and
student housing, but also by dwellings and commercial structures built for
the fledgling merchant class that provided goods and services to the college
population.
Profound change came to Davidson in 1874, when the
reactivation of the railroad linking Charlotte and Statesville removed
Davidson from its relative isolation and introduced forces that made the
town a commercial and industrial center for the rural environs of northern
Mecklenburg County and southern Iredell County. The late 1800s and early
1900s witnessed the rise of textile manufacturing in Davidson through the
construction of such notable structures as the Linden Mill and the Delburg
Mill. The mills had a significant impact on the nature of the built
environment of Davidson through the introduction of industrial buildings and
mill housing. The College continued to be important to the growth of
the town in the late 1800s and throughout the early and mid twentieth
century and also occasioned significant changes in the built environment
primarily through the introduction of faculty housing constructed in a
variety of styles.

1912 Sanborn Map depicting the Currie House at 759 North Main Street
The Currie House
The Currie House, a two-story dwelling that faces east on North Main
Street, is a tangible reminder of some the forces that shaped the Town of
Davidson in the early twentieth century.[i]
The long-time home of Archibald Currie and Lucy Martin Currie, the property
stands as a relic of the history of the town and it retains a connection to
the introduction of standardized graded education to the area.

The Currie House (right) circa 1911, soon after it was constructed.
Photograph courtesy of the Davidson College Archives.

The southern and rear elevations of the Currie House, circa 1915
Courtesy of the Davidson College Archives
The Currie family arrived in Davidson during a period
of expansion for the town and the Davidson College alike. Archibald Currie
was the son of Violet Currie, who was widowed in 1894 and moved to Davidson
to educate her sons while operating a boarding house on North Main Street.[ii]
Archibald Currie graduated from Davidson College in 1897 and received
further training at Columbia University, Cornell University, and the
University of Virginia.[iii]
He was appointed to the position of adjunct professor of Latin, Greek, and
mathematics at Davidson College in 1901, and by 1920 he was endowed with the
Woodrow Wilson Chair of Economics and Political Science at Davidson College.[iv]

Archibald Currie
Photograph courtesy of the Davidson College Archives
Although he is remembered most fondly as “a born
teacher and a thorough master of his subjects” at Davidson College,
Archibald Currie also contributed his time and expertise to the town in the
area of public education.[v]
In the period between the establishment of the college and the 1880s, the
system of education in Davidson and the region as a whole was informal at
best, a reflection of the rural character of North Carolina.
[vi]
Children attended common schools at the discretion of their parents, and the
education that took place in these common schools was generally limited by
the lack of a standardized curriculum, inconsistent attendance, and the
inadequate training of teachers.[vii]
This system of education was a reflection of the priorities of the society
of a whole, in which schooling received in a public setting was but one
facet of a child’s education. In an agrarian system predicated upon custom
and tradition, a child’s education was received not only in the schoolhouse,
but also in the fields, at the hearth, and in the church.[viii]
In Davidson, the traditional education that students
received was supplemented at schools taught by local residents. One of the
earliest of these schools was that of Mrs. Julia Holt, who held a school for
girls in Tammany Hall, a two-story building that once stood between
Philanthropic Hall and Elm Row on the Davidson College campus.[ix]
Between 1875 and the mid-1880s, many Davidson children attended Lucy
Jurney’s “School for Boys and Girls” in the building known as Lingle Manor
on Glasgow Street, the same building that housed the Reverend Leonidas
Glasgow’s school between 1887 and 1892.[x]
In 1893, the Shelton family donated a lot on South Street, where the current
Davidson IB Middle School is located, to be used for the purposes of
education. The original school, known to Davidsonians as the “Davidson
Academy,” was, as historian Mary Beaty notes, a combination of public and
private school in which students were expected to pay tuition in the fall
and spring, but the winter term was free of charge, and therefore, the most
popular of the terms.
[xi]
Archibald Currie demonstrated his commitment to public education early in
his career. After his graduation from Davidson College in 1897, he served as
the principal of the Davidson Academy from 1898 until 1902, where he met his
future wife, Lucy Battle Martin, who worked as a teacher at the Academy.[xii]
The rapidly-changing world of the late
nineteenth-century challenged the traditional beliefs about public
education. The forces of industrialization drew farmers out from the fields
and into newly formed commercial centers. Proponents of the graded school
movement in North Carolina espoused the idea that the “new order” of the
world dictated a change in the style of education towards a system that gave
students the tools to succeed within an increasingly modernized society.[xiii]
Legislation establishing graded school districts was approved of in North
Carolina at a quickening pace. The public seemed to agree with the graded
school proponents who held that the modern world required the
“professionalism and standardization” required of the new schools that were
supported by special local taxes.[xiv]
Davidson’s graded school was established in 1911, and the statute that
established the school provided for a board of trustees to oversee the
operations of the school. Archibald Currie again demonstrated his
commitment to public education and served as a member of the board of
trustees from the establishment of the graded school in 1911 until at least
1926.[xv]
The importance that Archibald Currie placed on
education was echoed by other members of the Currie family. Archibald’s
brother, Thomas, also served as principal of the Davidson Academy. His
wife, Lucy, was a teacher at the Academy, and Letitia Currie, the daughter
of Archibald and Lucy, is fondly remembered in town as a long-serving eighth
grade teacher at Davidson Elementary School. Letita returned to Davidson
when her father became ill, after resigning her position as a professor at
Peace College in Raleigh[xvi]

Lucy Martin Currie and her daughters, Letitia (seated) and Lucy
That Archibald and Lucy Martin Currie became such
integral parts of the Town of Davidson is perhaps little surprise. The town
developed as a consequence of the establishment of the College, and as such,
many of the faculty members and their families who have settled in Davidson
have made permanent contributions to the growth of the town, creating a
sense of interconnectedness between the town and the college. Although
Archibald Currie was a full-time professor at the College, he also served
the town as an attorney and in his work for public education. A further
example of this close relationship exists in Lucy Battle Martin Currie, who
is remembered as “the first lady of the town,” a woman who “contributed more
towards giving the village the cultural tone which long distinguished it”
than any other resident.[xvii]
Lucy Currie was the daughter of Davidson College president Colonel William
J. Martin and the sister of Davidson College president Dr. William J.
Martin. She was born in the President’s House on North Main Street, and
became a life-long resident of the town. After Lucy was widowed in 1942,
she threw herself into a number of endeavors that aimed to share her love
for learning with the community. In addition to establishing and
participating in several prominent social groups, such as the Thelemite Book
Club, Lucy also lectured to students at the middle school about the history
of the town in which they lived.[xviii]
Mrs. Currie was the embodiment of the symbiotic relationship between the
town and the College.
Lucy Martin Currie strove for excellence in her life
and achieved it in fields that were not generally open to women at the
beginning of the twentieth century. Lucy was “a feminist before there was
feminism,” remembers her grand-daughter, Tish Kimbrough, and she was one of
the first females to graduate from the Davidson College. Although Davidson
College did not officially begin to admit females until the 1970s, the
faculty briefly agreed to allow young women from the town to take classes
during the 1860s. Two women from Davidson completed the four-year course in
classical studies, but the experiment in co-education was abandoned by the
end of the decade.[xix]
The College again began to allow females to take classes in the 1890s, and
while they were not listed as students in the Davidson Catalogue, it is
known that at least six females took advantage of this educational
opportunity.[xx]
There was certainly a desire by some parts of the Davidson population to
have the benefits of higher education extended to the local women. By 1891,
the opinion was publicly expressed that if Davidson College allowed for
co-education then perhaps “instead of losing so many of our own Davidson
girls [to regional colleges for females] we would be in a fair position to
import some others.”[xxi]
Lucy Martin began classes at Davidson College in 1894 and completed the
four-year course in 1899.[xxii]
While as many as seven young ladies took classes at Davidson in the 1890s,
it is unclear how many, other than Lucy Martin, actually completed the
four-year course of study until 1901, when a certificate was issued to
another female graduate.[xxiii]
An even greater honor was bestowed upon her when, in 1904, Lucy Martin
traveled to Oxford, England, to study with the first group of American
Rhodes scholars. Although the group officially consisted of only men, Lucy
Martin shared in many of the same social and educational experiences as her
male cohorts.[xxiv]
The Currie House is an important reminder of the
history of both the Town of Davidson and the accomplishments of the Currie
family. The Currie family has helped to shape generations of future
Davidsonians through their association with public education in the town.
Furthermore, the accomplishments of Lucy Martin Currie illuminate her as not
only a prominent and influential Davidsonian, but as a singularly
accomplished woman in the early twentieth century.
Architectural
Description

The Currie House, front elevation, 2006
Exterior Description
The Currie House, built in 1911, exhibits an interesting interplay of a
late Victorian, asymmetrical plan with a restrained Victorian and
Arts-and-Crafts influence in its detailing. One of the distinctive
characteristics of the home is its location in relation to North Main
Street. While the other dwellings in this section of Davidson were built
close to the road, the Currie House sits almost one hundred and twenty-four
feet back from North Main Street. The lot on which the dwelling rests is
only about seventy feet wide on the boundary with the street but it is
almost three hundred and seventy feet long. The rear perimeter of the
property is defined by the railroad that extends in a north-south direction
on the western edge of the property, and at almost eight hundred and thirty
feet above sea level, the Currie House was built atop one of the highest
points in Davidson. The lot slopes gently away from the home towards the
front and rear of the lot. A sharp embankment is present at the rear of the
property, at the bottom of which are the railroad tracks.
|

|

|
|
View towards North Main Street from the
front porch of the Currie House |
View from the rear of the lot towards the
rear of the Currie House |
|

|
|
View from the top of the embankment on the
rear boundary of the Currie lot to the train tracks below |
Although the Currie House has had renovations to the
interior and the exterior in recent years, much of the home retains its
original elements and the renovations have been consistent with the
architectural character of the home. The Sanborn Map of Davidson for 1912
shows the Currie House as a two-story tall dwelling with a central cubic
massing, with ells extending to the north and west and projecting bays on
the east and south elevations. The Sanborn Maps also indicate that the home
has a wraparound front porch, and that the rear of the dwelling held a
one-story tall porch. All of these features of the exterior of the home
remain, with the exception of the rear porch, which has been enclosed, and
the addition of a small, shed-roofed mudroom on the rear façade.
The two-story tall home faces east on North Main Street
and it has a high hipped roof that is covered in asphalt shingle with a
two-story, gable-roofed projecting bay on the front façade and a two-story,
hipped-roof ell on the north façade, respectively. The brick foundation
has been reinforced in places with concrete, and most of the home is covered
in the original wooden clapboard siding. The central brick chimney has a
corbelled cap and was recently rebuilt, but another brick chimney on the
rear of the home appears to be original.
The front façade of the house is three bays wide. A
two-story tall, gable-roofed projecting bay protrudes from the left side of
the front façade, and wooden shingle cladding is present under the gable.
The front elevation has a stepped appearance, taken as a whole with the
projecting bay and the visible portion of the northern ell that is connected
to the front façade by the wraparound porch. This one-story front porch has
a hipped roof that is covered in asphalt shingle. The porch floor is
composed of four-inch wooden planks that are of recent origin, although the
boards which cover the porch ceiling do appear to be original. The siding on
the porch is dissimilar to the siding on the remainder of the house. While
the original siding is wooden clapboard, the porch is clad in wooden German
siding. The heavy square posts which support the roof of the front porch
are devoid of ornamentation and appear to be original, as do the square
spindles that line the banister. On the center bay of the front façade is
the original two-paneled entry, which holds two lights. A secondary
entrance which consists of a paneled door with two lights is present on the
north-facing cross-gable. The windows on the front façade are the original
eight-over-one double-hung sash windows, and the asymmetrical arrangement of
the lights in the windows as well as the distinctive lights on the entry
suggest the influence of the Arts-and-Crafts movement. The windows are
paired on both stories of the front-facing cross gable, but they are single
on the center bay and on the right bay. The porch’s brick foundation was
also recently rebuilt.
|

|

|
|
Front door of the Currie House |
Detail of German siding on the porch |
|

|
|
Detail of original, eight-over-one sash windows |
The north elevation of the Currie House is four bays
wide, and is dominated by the two-story, hipped-roof ell which projects out
from the rear of the cubic massing. There are paired, eight-over-one sash
windows that are original to the home on both the first and second story of
this wing. The left bay is composed of the northern section of the
wraparound porch and the front section of the house. Two fixed windows with
muntins that are arranged in a lattice pattern are found on the first and
second stories of this bay. The one-story tall ell which extends from the
rear façade is also visible from the north elevation. This ell holds two
individual replacement sash windows that mirror the eight-over-one light
arrangement of the original windows.

Rear
elevation of the Currie House
From the rear of the Currie House, which is
three-bays-wide, it is possible to view the two-story tall ell which once
held a sleeping porch on the second story. The ell has a hipped roof, and
the original windows on the second story have been replaced with modern
casement windows which retain the historic character of their predecessors.
The former sleeping porch is clad in board-and-batten siding of recent
origin. The one-story extension of this ell also has a hipped roof and a
tripartite window that is not original to the home, but maintains the
asymmetrical appearance of the original windows of the house. There is also
a one-story tall wing with a hipped roof which was originally a porch, but
has been enclosed, and a shed-roofed mud room has been added. The paneled
exterior door and the fixed window with muntins arranged in a lattice work
pattern are both original to the house, although they were moved from their
original location. The left bay of this elevation holds an exterior brick
chimney with shaped shoulders.
|

|

|
|
South elevation of the Currie House |
Detail of the southern projecting bay |
The four-bay-wide south elevation contains one of the
most distinctive features of the dwelling. An eight foot wide bay projects
out of the first story of the central massing. This bay has a hipped roof
covered in standing seam metal, and was designed specifically to hold a
large mahogany sideboard that the Currie family inherited from Lucy Currie’s
family, the Martins. The sideboard around which this bay was constructed is
now housed in the Davidson College library. The projecting bay is about
eight feet wide, and contains a center fixed window that is flanked by two
casement windows, all of which have a lattice arrangement of muntins. There
are two additional casement windows on the east and west sides of this
projecting bay.
The windows on the south elevation are the original
eight-over-one sash windows with the exception of the replacement windows on
the south side of the former sleeping porch and a four-light casement window
on the first story. The sash windows over the projecting bay are paired,
while the remainder of the windows are single.
Interior Description
|

|

|
|
First floor plan of the Currie House. Note that the new bath was
ultimately constructed within the hallway, thus freeing the hallway
from the front door to the kitchen. |
Second floor plan of the Currie House |
Much of the interior of the Currie House retains the
original wood trim and detailing. The main entry gives access to a long
hallway whose floors are of two-and-a-half inch wide wooden boards. These
boards cover much of the first story, with the exception of the kitchen and
the bathroom, which have both undergone renovations and hold new wooden
flooring. Two distinctive features of the hallway are the alcove which once
held a wood stove and the wide stairway, which retains its original molded
handrail, wooden turned spindles, and square newels.
|

|

|
|
First floor staircase |
Living room, first floor |
In addition to the original wood flooring, the three
generously proportioned, square rooms on the first floor all have the
original, wide baseboards topped with molded caps, and each room contains
the original fireplaces. The fireplace in the living room is in excellent
condition, and it features the original wooden posts that support the heavy
wooden mantle. The dining room contains a built-in china cabinet which has
the same lattice-work windows as the casement windows in the projecting bay
across the room from it. The sitting room, like the dining room, contains
the original fireplace, which has been converted from a coal burning
appliance to a gas-burning appliance. The molding surrounding the door of
the media room has also been slightly altered. The interior doors to all of
the rooms on the first floor are original to the home and each entry
displays the original engraved hardware.
|

|

|
|
Dining room, including china cabinet |
Sitting room |
The second story of the Currie House holds three square bedrooms,
similarly proportioned to the rooms on the first floor. Like the rooms on
the first floor, these bedrooms all largely contain the original wood trim
and fireplaces. The bedroom in the northwest corner of the home has had
minor alterations to accommodate the addition of a laundry room, and the
bedroom in the southwest corner of the home has had a closet added. In
addition, the floor boards in the bedrooms on the south face of the home are
three inches wide, slightly wider than the original floors throughout the
remainder of the home.
The renovations to the Currie House have been limited
to the kitchen, the bathrooms, and the transformation of the sleeping porch
to a new master bath. However, in each of these rooms, the finished product
roughly mirrors the original proportions of the room in question, and the
owners were conscientious about including replacement windows that reflect
the historic character of the home, and, when possible, employing original
doors and windows.
Outbuildings
The Currie House has two outbuildings, both of which are significantly
removed from the rear of the home. The oldest of these two outbuildings is
a metal shed that is largely deteriorated. There is also a two-part, cedar
plank-clad shed. The walls of this structure splay outwards slightly before
meeting with the gabled roofs, underneath which the rafter tails are
visible. The roofs are covered in asphalt shingle. The cedar shed is
approximately fourteen feet deep by eleven feet wide, and is accessed by an
eight foot long plank walkway. The entry is contained on the larger of the
two gabled masses.

She
[i]
Mecklenburg County, North Carolina, Register of Deeds, Book 263-126.
[ii]
Mary D. Beaty, Davidson, A History of the Town from 1835 Until
1937 (Davidson, NC: Briarpatch Press, 1979), 91.
[iii]
Cornelia Rebekah Shaw, Davidson College (New York: Fleming H.
Revell Press, 1923), 175.
[v]
“Excerpt from the Davidson College Faculty Minutes of February 26,
1943,” Currie-Johnston Family Papers, Davidson College Archives,
Davidson College.
[vi]
James M. Leloudis, Schooling the New South: Self, Pedagogy, and
Society in North Carolina, 1880-1920 (Chapel Hill: University of
North Carolina Press, 1996), 6
[xii]
Ibid., 179; Jennifer Payne, interview with Tish Kimbrough,
grand-daughter of Archibald and Lucy Currie, 20 July, 2006.
[xvi]
Currie and Johnston Papers; Beaty, 179: Payne interview with Tish
Kimbrough.
[xvii]
Lucy Martin Currie obituary, Currie-Johnston papers.
[xviii] Payne interview with Tish Kimbrough.
[xix]
Quips and Cranks, 1900, 76, available in the Davidsoniana
Room in the Little Library on the campus of Davidson College.
[xx]
Mary D. Beaty, A History of Davidson College (Davidson:
Briarpatch Press, 1988), 198.
[xxi]
Davidsonian Monthly, “Locals,” October, 1891, 27-28. The
Davidsonian Monthly is available in the Davidsoniana Room of the
Little Library of Davidson College.
[xxiii] Beaty, A History of Davidson College,
198.
[xxiv]
Letter to Lucy Martin from an unidentified fellow scholar, Currie
and Johnston Papers.
|