|

The Historic Landmarks Commission will meet
next on November 13, 2006, in its offices in the
Ratcliffe-Otterbourg House at 2100
Randolph Road, Charlotte, N.C. The meeting shall commence at 6:00 p.m.
Anyone needing assistance should contact the Historic Landmarks Commission
beforehand at 704-376-9115.
AGENDA
1. Approval of Minutes.
Click here for draft of minutes.
2. Director's Report.
Click here for Director's Report
a. Archives and History Review of
prospective landmarks
Background information. Within
the last six months the content and tone of comment letters from the North
Carolina Division of Archives and History regarding prospective historic
landmarks has changed. Heretofore the letters, which are advisory in
nature, have generally supported designation and have advanced few questions
about claims for special significance for prospective landmarks. That
is no longer true.
As a general rule, except when properties
appear to be substantially endangered, staff will not be bringing properties
before the Commission until the comment letters have been received. As
a first step staff is bringing to your attention letters regarding
properties the Commission has already recommended for designation but for
which the joint public hearing has not been held.
1) Click
here for comment letter on the Holt-Henderson-Copeland House.

Click Here
For Staff Response
2)
Click here for comment letter on Restormel

Click
Here For Staff Response
3) Click
here for comment letter of Armour Adams House

Click Here
For Staff Reponse
4)
Click here for comment letter on the Cashion-Moore Cemetery

Click
Here For Staff Response
5) Click here
for comment letter on the Charlotte City House

Click
Here For Staff Response
3 Design Review Matters.
Click here for minutes.
a. Application For A Certificate Of
Appropriateness For The Home Federal Savings and Loan Building.
 |
|
Home Federal Savings and
Loan |
The Committee considered this issue and passed the
following motion:
MR. SHURLEY PRESENTED A MOTION SECONDED BY MR. WEIS
TO RECOMMEND TO THE HISTORIC LANDMARKS COMMISSION THAT THE APPLICATION
FOR A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS FOR THE HOME FEDERAL SAVINGS AND
LOAN BUILDING, 139 SOUTH TRYON STREET, CHARLOTTE, N. C., BE APPROVED AS
SUBMITTED. THE COMMITTEE APPROVED THE MOTION AS PRESENTED.
APPROVE: MR. BENSON, MR. SHURLEY, MR. WEIS AND MR.
NORMAN OPPOSE: MR. ALSOP, MS. JOHNSON, AND MS. LEWIS
Click
Here For Plans.
Staff Recommendation:
Approve Motion As Presented.
b. Consideration Of Preservation Plan
For The Coffee Cup Soda Grill.
Background: At its October meeting the
Commission deferred action on the Survey Committee's recommendation that the
Coffee Cup Soda Grill be recommended for historic landmark designation.
The reason for this delay was to give the owner, Beazer Homes, Inc., the
opportunity to meet with members of the Commission to devise a possible
preservation solution for the subject property. The details of the
proposed solution were presented to the Design Review Committee, and the
Committee passed the following motion.MR. WEIS PRESENTED A MOTION SECONDED BY MR. SHURLEY
TO RECOMMEND TO THE HISTORIC LANDMARKS COMMISSION THAT IT NOT ACCEPT THE
PLANS PROPOSED BY BEAZER HOMES FOR THE COFFEE CUP SODA GRILL, 914 SOUTH
CLARKSON STREET, CHARLOTTE, N. C. THE COMMITTEE APPROVED THE MOTION.
APPROVE: ALSOP, JOHNSON, LEWIS, SHURLEY, WEIS
OPPOSE: BENSON, NORMAN
Click Here
For Proposed Solution Page One.
Click Here
For Proposed Solution Page Two.
Staff Recommendation:
Staff has found that the subject property does meet the requisite standards
for special significance for prospective historic landmarks. However,
the Commission needs to take into account and be sensitive to the wishes of
the owner, who is opposed to historic landmark designation.
The Commission passed the following motion in
January 1999. This is the current policy governing the actions of the
Commission regarding recommending properties for historic landmark
designation over owner opposition.
| MR. MARTIN PRESENTED A
SUBSTITUTE MOTION, SECONDED BY MR. WHITNEY, THAT THE HLC WILL BE
SENSITIVE AND RESPECTFUL OF AN OWNER’S DESIRE REGARDING
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR PROCESSING AN OWNER’S PROPERTY, BUT THAT THE HLC,
AFTER DELIBERATE CONSIDERATION, WILL RECOMMEND THE PROCESSING OF
PROPERTIES FOR HISTORIC DESIGNATION IF IT DEEMS THAT THE PROPERTY IS
WORTHY OF CONSIDERATION FOR DESIGNATION IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE
PREVAILING GUIDELINES. THE HLC UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED THE MOTION. |
Click Here For Letter From North Carolina Division of Archives and History
concerning the issue of special significance for the Coffee Cup Soda Grill.
|